DEFRA has just published its Agricultural Transition Plan for England (after our newsletter went to press!) which sets out the direction of agricultural policy for the next generation. This follows the Agricultural Act being made law and is potentially the biggest change to farming policy since 1947. The plan has the twin priorities of a competitive agricultural industry alongside acting on the environment, climate change and animal welfare. These policies have been developing over the last few years and specifically since the 2016 referendum.

 

The Transition Plan is extensive with a huge amount of detail, but the main themes cover the Basic Payment Scheme, Environmental Land Management, Productivity and Regulations. We have summarised as best we can, but such is the scale of the changes proposed, a lot of detail is needed and cannot be skimmed over.

 

  1. Basic Payment Scheme

Inevitably, the reductions in Basic Payment are the most immediately noteworthy features of the policy document as the replacement schemes are not yet finalised, nor is the balance of future payments. By 2024, Basic Payment will be halved with the money released to be used to support DEFRA’s other goals of environmental, productivity and animal welfare improvements. The reductions will be as follows:

 

Annual BPS 2021 2022 2023 2024
Up to £30,000 5% 20% 35% 50%
£30 –50,000 10% 25% 40% 55%
£50 –150,000 20% 35% 50% 65%
Over £150,000 25% 40% 55% 70%

 

There will be a lump sum payment option from 2022, where farmers can capitalise all future payments as a form of retirement package or as an incentive for less efficient businesses to exit the industry. De-linking will happen in 2024, meaning that payments will no longer be linked to land from this point.

 

  1. Environmental Land Management Scheme (ELMS)

This is the key scheme for the delivery of improvements to the environment and to addresses climate change issues. ELMS will no longer have numbered tiers but named ‘components’ with what appears, in effect, to be a phased introduction as it is rolled out from later in 2021 until 2028:

  • the Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) (formerly Tier 1) – This is intended to give as many farmers as possible the chance to be paid for ‘public goods’ management above baseline regulations. Sitting initially alongside the continuing Countryside Stewardship scheme, it is expected to emphasise soil health, nutrient management and Integrated Pest Management. This is to be piloted in 2021/2022 with the aim of 1,000 farms.
  • Local Nature Recovery (formerly Tier 2) – As the title implies, the options for more significant work on species, habitats and land use change are likely to very much location specific.
  • Landscape Recovery (formerly Tier 3) – This is for landscape and eco-system recovery which will have large scale example projects from 2022. As the title implies, this is aimed at a larger scale and so might more usually see collaborative activity, perhaps over areas of 2-3,000 hectares.

 

These schemes will often involve an adviser, leading to a Land Management Plan and then to a contract between the farmer and government. DEFRA has indicated that agreement lengths could range from annual for, say, a basic SFI contract to multiple year agreements where there is more commitment required for more major changes in land management.

 

Countryside Stewardship (CS) will continue to operate with applications possible up to 2023. DEFRA is looking for a smooth path for people to move from CS (and older HLS agreements) to ELMS without penalty. The CS inspections regime is to be improved from 2021 to be more proportionate and focused on outcomes. Woodland creation and tree planting will also be supported. A Pilot for the Tree Health Scheme will run in 2021 with a view to a launch in 2024.

 

The Animal Health and Welfare Pathway will also be brought in from 2022 to support farmers in producing healthier, higher welfare animals by offering capital grants and additional financial support.

 

  1. Productivity

This covers a few different areas and there will be a range of initiatives:

  • The Farm Investment Fund will have grants for productivity and technology under two levels:
    • A Farming Equipment Technology Fund offering smaller grants to contribute towards the purchase of a list of specified items.
    • A Farming Transformation Fund offering larger grants for more substantial investments in equipment, technology or infrastructure; aiming at transforming business performance.
  • New Entrant Support Scheme is being designed to create opportunities for new entrants to access land, infrastructure and support to establish successful and innovative businesses working with Council Farms and other landowners.
  • Slurry Investment will help farmers to invest in new slurry stores that exceed current regulatory requirements and are proofed against higher standards that are expected in the future.
  • Support for Innovation, Research and Development to bring together researchers, farmers, growers and other agri-food businesses to harness science, increase productivity and reduce the environmental impact of agriculture.
  • Future Farming Resilience Support to act through existing support organisations to help farmers with the transition in a three year programme starting from 2021
  • the Institute for Agriculture and Horticulture (IAH) will be established to be the home of professional development and training for the industry.

 

  1. Regulation and Enforcement

2021 should see improvements in cross compliance by moving away from financial penalties, instead using more proportionate measures and better communication. The aim is to change the tone of Rural Payments Agency interactions with farmers to make them more constructive and advisory.

 

 

Our initial thoughts…

Basic Payments are set to be phased out over the seven year Agricultural Transition period, from 2021 to 2027, so that there will be no Basic Payment in 2028. Farms, estates and families will need to decide how they will adapt, whether by improving efficiency and using new technology, generational or structural change, developing new enterprises or seeing opportunities in the environment. The phasing of change from 2021 to 2027 allows time for those choices and changes to be made.

 

Consistent area payments have possibly shielded some businesses from the harsh realities of technological development, world markets, public tastes and environmental challenges. Future ‘public money’ will only be available to farmers delivering on the ‘public goods’ of environmental, animal welfare and climate change outcomes. The transition period will remove that shield and will require the industry to evolve or face an uncertain future.