Any farm tenancies starting today are almost certainly going to be Farm Business Tenancies (FBT’s) under the Agricultural Tenancies Act 1995. Existing and new FBT’s are governed by specific legislation which dictates how they operate and what the parties can and can’t do. We explore these points and some other FBT related issues below.
Is a tenancy already in place?
If a tenant is already in occupation, it is very important to consider when the tenancy started, to ascertain what type of tenancy you have in place. It doesn’t matter if anything is written down or not, it depends entirely on how the parties have acted, irrespective of what might have been said or agreed.
If the tenant was on the land prior to 1 September 1995, it may already be an Agricultural Holdings Act 1986 Tenancy (“AHA”) which means the tenant has a right to remain on the land for their lifetime. If there was occupation prior to 12 July 1984, there could also be succession rights. If you have an AHA, there are very limited circumstances where possession can be obtained by a landlord. The law for AHA’s is much more prescriptive than for FBT’s so it is key to take advice early to make sure you are doing the right thing.
If the land has been occupied from a date after 1 September 1995, it will likely mean you have an FBT.
What else makes an FBT?
To qualify as an FBT, the land must be farmed throughout the tenancy as part of a trade or business. The landlord and tenant can also exchange notices before the tenancy starts to confirm their intention for the tenancy to remain an FBT throughout its duration. This can ensure that the tenancy stays as an FBT even if the actual use diversifies away from farming. This is especially important these days as diversification can happen quickly and soon take over from the main farming enterprise.
Consider the terms you will need to include
Before agreeing a lease and signing any tenancy agreement, you should consider a variety of issues to ensure that the terms and requirements for the tenancy are known and written down at the start. There are many issues to consider and here are a few questions that can help start things off:
- What is the rent and when should it be paid?
- How long should the tenancy last?
- Who are the actual landlord and tenant? (this is often more complex that it might first appear)
- What are the access arrangements?
- What third party easements exist?
- Is the land within any environmental schemes?
- Are there any land designations that affect how it can be managed?
- Are there an outstanding planning permissions?
- Who will be responsible for maintenance?
Avoid surprises on rent reviews
When negotiating a farm business tenancy, it’s up to the parties to agree the frequency of rent review, or to agree that there will be no rent review. If there is to be a review, both parties can agree a set increase or formula for calculating rent. If nothing is agreed, under the legislation, either party can demand a rent review every three years. Making rent review arrangements part of the tenancy wording will help avoid nasty surprises or difficult conversations further down the line.
Understand compensation arrangements
Tenants are entitled to receive compensation at the end of the tenancy for physical improvements made to the farm, providing such improvements were made with the landlord’s consent.
Tenants can also be entitled to compensation for any other improvements which increase the value of the holding, for example the obtaining of planning permission, providing such improvements remain with the farm when the tenant leaves. Landlords and tenants are free to agree an upper limit on the amount of any compensation payable and this must be in writing.
How do FBT’s end?
There are clear rules around termination of FBT’s. For example, if the tenancy is granted for a fixed term of two years or less, it will end automatically at the end of the fixed term without notice from either party. If the tenancy is a yearly tenancy, or a fixed term longer than two years, notice of a minimum of 12 months must be given by either party to expire on an anniversary of the start of tenancy.
So, a minimum of 12 months’ notice means planning the termination of the lease is vital as if you get the timing slightly wrong, it could be almost two years before the next opportunity to end the lease comes around.
Consider the tax issues
This is often overlooked when tenancies are agreed but depending on the length and value of the lease, the tenant will be responsible for paying Stamp Duty Land Tax. In addition, if the lease is for longer than seven years it needs to be registered at the Land Registry against the landlord’s title.
There are also other issues that landlords often need to think about as the presence of a tenancy can have big inheritance tax implications for landowners.
Take advice
Entering into an FBT or managing an existing one is not something you should do without taking professional advice. There are just too many variables that can be overlooked. A rural surveyor is best placed to help you draw up your tenancy as they understand the nuances of agricultural tenancies.
