We have been working through and setting up out first batch of Sustainable Farming Inventive (SFI) agreements so now have much more of a feel for how they work and how attractive they might be.

Our initial findings are cautiously positive. Compared to Countryside Stewardship, the application process is more straightforward and the rules and regulations are more flexible, with payments rates being identical for comparable options but with an extra agreement level payment and more flexibility.

If we compare one specific option, GS2 low input grassland in Countryside Stewardship and LIG1 low input grassland under SFI, we find the following:

  • GS2 has a complete ban on supplementary feeding, whereas LIG1 allows supplementary feeding as long as it does not cause poaching.
  • GS2 has a strict ban on any cutting or mechanical activities between 15 March and 30 June, whereas LIG1 allows more flexibility to this, as long as the field is shut up for at least 7 weeks before taking the cut.
  • SFI agreements are for three years not the five years you would have to commit to under Stewardship.
  • The payments rates are the same at Β£151/ha or Β£61/acre.
  • In addition, all SFI agreement holders get an extra management payment of Β£20/ha/year for the first 50 hectares of land under an agreement. This is designed to cover the administrative and management time required to manage an SFI agreement.

As can be seen, there are distinct advantages to SFI when compared to Countryside Stewardship. Although, whilst there is flexibility, there is also more onus on the farmer to make sure that however they are managing the land is sufficient to deliver the action’s aim. If there was ever a question over whether a farmer was compliant, they would need to be able to demonstrate, with field records and evidence, that they had been doing enough.

The other drawback to SFI is that it is currently quite limited with only 23 actions to pick from and with no capital options at all. However, for those looking to enter an agri-environment scheme for the first time, or looking to compliment an existing scheme, SFI is definitely worth considering.

See our post from earlier this year for a full list of the actions and payment rates: Sustainable Farming Incentive – 2023 Relaunch | CPW Daniell